James Holzhauer, the trivia whiz who dominated Jeopardy! this spring, isn’t invincible after all.
The game show’s 32-time champion lost for the first time in an episode that aired Monday, falling short of records for total winnings and longest reign, but still making an argument that he’s the best to ever play television’s most popular game.
The professional sports gambler from Las Vegas ended his run by high-fiving the woman who beat him, Chicago librarian Emma Boettcher.
“I really felt like I had been playing with house money, so I wasn’t too upset to see my run end,” Holzhauer said in an email interview. He said he ran into “a terrific opponent playing flawlessly.”
The streak made Holzhauer a household name and sent ratings soaring at a time Jeopardy! needed a pick-me-up following host Alex Trebek’s announcement that he had cancer
Holzhauer nearly doubled the show’s previous record for one-day winnings by earning $131,127 US on his 10th game, and he leaves with the 16 highest one-day scores in the show’s history.
He combined a savant-like knowledge of the world with a mastery of the buzzer, allowing him to beat opponents to the punch, and adding a gambler’s cold-blooded instinct to make big bets.
Often in the show’s first round, he’d quickly pile up as much money as he could, and then bet it all if he landed on a Daily Double, which allows contestants to choose how much money to risk.
In the end, he ran into a woman willing to be as bold as he was. Boettcher went into the show’s final question with a lead over Holzhauer, and bet $20,201 US to ensure he couldn’t beat her.
“What a game!” Trebek said. “Oh, my God.”
The show’s final clue was: “The line ‘a great reckoning in a little room’ in As You Like It is usually taken to refer to this author’s premature death.”
Both Boettcher and Holzhauer correctly answered, “Who is Christopher Marlowe?”
Holzhauer had won $2,462,216 US through Friday’s episode, leaving him a little more than $58,000 shy of the record for earnings set by Ken Jennings in 2004. Holzhauer didn’t get halfway to Jennings’ 74-game win streak.
“I was surprised to see James go down considering how unbeatable he has looked, but it just goes to show how fragile a Jeopardy! streak is,” Jennings said on Monday. “The end is always just one bad break away.”
Holzhauer, who rarely buzzed in with wrong answers, said he was proud that he never beat himself.
“It took an incredible performance to knock me out,” he said.
Holzhauer’s intimidating dominance became so routine that some longtime Jeopardy! watchers groused that it was becoming boring. Holzhauer himself seemed subdued during his last few victories. He said there was an explanation: last week’s episodes were taped immediately after Trebek announced his cancer diagnosis, so that might have affected his mood.
“I don’t think I ever tired of playing,” he said. “I greatly enjoyed the whole experience.”
Word that Monday’s episode might turn out to be special for Jeopardy! fans spread quickly with circulation late this weekend of a video of the show’s final minute. A show representative did not immediately respond to questions about how this material was leaked.
Holzhauer himself offered a cryptic tweet hours before most of the country had seen the episode. Savvy sports fans would recognize the reference to a supposed curse that rap star Drake brings to teams he roots for.
— James Holzhauer (@James_Holzhauer) June 3, 2019
Holzhauer developed an active social media presence during his time on the show, a signal that he’s likely to be heard from again. He said that “I’m fielding some very interesting offers at the moment, and still have a lot of phone calls to return.”
Jennings was already seeing questions Monday about whether Jeopardy! would bring him and Holzhauer together for an epic championship match.
“It would be hard to turn down, but I’d feel like the old gunslinger being challenged by the young guy in his prime,” he said. “On the right day, I’m sure I could still take him, but it would all be a matter of who got the breaks.”